Forget Foyet. Ranking the Most H0rr1fic Major UnSubs on ‘Criminal Minds’, The Number 1 UnSub Will Haunt Your Nlghtmares — Here’s Why... See more!

Home

Forget Foyet. Ranking the Most H0rr1fic Major UnSubs on ‘Criminal Minds’, The Number 1 UnSub Will Haunt Your Nlghtmares — Here’s Why... See more!

2026/06/03 Report

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s be real — “Criminal Minds” didn’t just give us creepy episodes. It gave us nightmares we still haven’t fully processed. And with the show celebrating 20 years since its very first episode (yes, back in 2005, when flip phones were still cool), TV Insider decided to do something both brilliant and terrifying: rank the most horrific major UnSubs from the original run.

ADVERTISEMENT

Spoiler alert: the top three will make you want to sleep with the lights on.

9. Ian Doyle
If Doyle (Timothy V. Murphy) had actually killed Prentiss (Paget Brewster) — instead of almost succeeding in doing so — he might be higher up on this list.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

ADVERTISEMENT

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

Next page

12 Years Later, I Don't Think Criminal Minds Will Ever Top Its Most Disturbing Unsub Storyline (& It Still Gives Me Chills) 😱❄️

"This One Was Difficult": Criminal Minds: Evolution Star AJ Cook On Carrying Will's Funeral Scene

It Just Broke ‘Criminal Minds’ Fans More Than Any Case — And What Evolution’ Boss & Adam Rodriguez Reveals Next Will Destroy You... See more!

‘Criminal Minds’ Star Adam Rodriguez Watches First Scene: ‘Can’t Say No to Rossi’ 🔥

Criminal Minds: Evolution Season 18 Episode 1 Recap: Is Voit Connected With Franklin Fowler? 💥

At First, It Saved the Show — Now It’s Hurting ‘Criminal Minds: Evolution’

😱🔥 Breaking Update: BAU Faces Chilling Showdown With Voit—Season 19’s Darkest Secrets Revealed Soon! #CriminalMindsEvolution

🔥 Emotional Speech Alert: Prentiss Rallies BAU After Tara’s Shooting — But Admits She’s Tired of Voit

😱🔥Breaking: The Creepiest Child Killer in *Criminal Minds* Could Return — Is Danny Murphy Now an Adult Monster?

Where Are My Legs: The Most Disturbing Criminal Minds Episode Still Gives Me Sleepless Nights 13 Years Later

💥 Attention, Crime Drama Addicts! Every “Criminal Minds” Season Is Finally Here — But You’ll Need to Hurry!

Heart-Stopping Drama: 16 Years Later, Fans Are Struggling to Finish Criminal Minds' Most Watched Episode💔

‘It’s So Satisfying, You’ll Cry’: Kirsten Vangsness Teases Emotional and Unexpected Criminal Minds: Evolution Ending 🎢

The Most Heartbreaking Scene in Criminal Minds – As Chosen by the Cast! 😭💔

10 Criminal Minds Reveals That Left Fans in Tears—You Won’t Believe Who Came Back From the Dead…

Shocking Secrets Unraveled: Criminal Minds: Evolution’s Jaw-Dropping Twist That No One Saw Coming! 🔥

What’s the Real Truth? Criminal Minds: Evolution Drops a Bombshell That Will Change Everything 💔

Spencer Reid’s Raw Emotion: Criminal Minds Fans Can't Stop Talking About His Tearful Breakdown 😢

Criminal Minds Fans Can't Handle Episode 4's Jaw-Dropping Twist Between JJ and Will! 🔥

Adam Rodriguez Just Revealed a ‘Criminal Minds: Evolution’ Season 20 Secret That Will Shock You... See more!