Sherlock Holmes has been played by over 70 actors. Only one of them has ever been asked to play both Holmes and his brother. What Benedict Cumberbatch said when someone suggested it — and why the answer reveals everything about how he understands both characters.

Home

Sherlock Holmes has been played by over 70 actors. Only one of them has ever been asked to play both Holmes and his brother. What Benedict Cumberbatch said when someone suggested it — and why the answer reveals everything about how he understands both characters.

2026/10/06 Report

ADVERTISEMENT

Someone Asked Benedict Cumberbatch to Play Both Sherlock and Mycroft Holmes. His Answer Was Two Words — And Then the Most Revealing Thing He's Said About Either Character.

The suggestion came from a journalist.

Not a serious production proposal — a hypothetical, the kind that interview contexts generate when the conversation has moved past prepared questions into the slightly looser territory where interesting things sometimes get said.

ADVERTISEMENT

What if, in some alternate version of the show, Cumberbatch had played both brothers?

He said no immediately. Two words. Then he stopped.

Then he explained why, and the explanation ran longer than any answer he had given in the interview to that point.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

ADVERTISEMENT

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

Next page

You've seen the show. You know the characters. But there's one casting decision from Series 1 that almost went a completely different direction — and the actor who nearly got Watson's role has spoken about it publicly only once.

The Sherlock Holmes stories have been translated into 60 languages. Only one translation caused an international incident. And the reason why tells you something surprising about what different cultures saw in the character.

Benedict Cumberbatch was in the middle of a press interview when someone showed him a piece of Sherlock fan art for the first time. His reaction lasted about four seconds. Those four seconds told you everything about how he actually feels about the people who love the show.

There is a piece of music in Sherlock that plays in only one scene. It has no official title. It was never released on the soundtrack album. But it has been searched for online more than any other piece of music from the show — because people hear it once and cannot forget it.

A researcher at a UK university spent three years studying how Sherlock fans talk about mental health online. What she found changed how she understood both the show and the people who love it.

There's a YouTube channel that has been uploading Sherlock scene analyses for eleven years. The person running it has never shown their face or revealed their name. Their most-viewed video has 4.2 million views. And their analysis of one specific scene changed how a significant portion of the fandom understands the show.

The BBC has released a lot of Sherlock behind-the-scenes content over the years. One short clip — uploaded in 2014, running just under three minutes — has more emotional impact than most full episodes of television. It shows something that was never supposed to be part of the show.

The original Sherlock Holmes stories contain a detail about Watson that most adaptations have quietly removed. The BBC series kept it — and hid it so well that most viewers missed it completely. Once you know where to look, you cannot unsee it.

Shocking Secret Wedding: Jersey Shore’s JWoww Stuns Fans with Intimate Ceremony

San Francisco 49ers’ George Kittle’s wife, Claire Kittle, clapped back at those judging her for drinking amid her IVF journey: “Mind Your Business!”

Heartbreaking News: Scary Mommy Founder Jill Smokler Passes Away at 48, Millions Mourn

Shocking Loss: Samantha Busch Breaks Silence on Life Without Kyle Busch After Father's Day Heartache

Dua Lipa SECRETLY MARRIED?! Jay-Z's Savage Freestyle EXPOSED Everyone? Cassie Is NEVER Coming Back? Sydney SNUBBED Zendaya?

50 Cent’s Love Life Isn’t “Messy”—It’s a Legal Battlefield: Fires, Custody Wars, and Money Pressure

Céline Dion’s Heartfelt Tribute to René Angélil Will Bring You to Tears 😢

‘Bling Empire: New York’ Star Lynn Ban Dead at 51 After Brain Surgery

Prince Williams Gives Kate Middleton Health Update Following Cancer Treatments

Beyoncé Becomes Most-Nominated Artist in Grammys History After JAY-Z Previously Called Out Awards for Snubbing Her

Unforgettable! The My Best Friend’s Wedding Cast Shares Behind-the-Scenes Stories of ‘I Say a Little Prayer’ 🎤

Ryan Reynolds reacts to Martha Stewart saying he's 'not so funny'