Thousands of Sherlock fans spent months convinced there was a secret fifth episode hidden inside Series 4. They weren't entirely wrong — and what they found will make you look at the finale very differently.

Home

Thousands of Sherlock fans spent months convinced there was a secret fifth episode hidden inside Series 4. They weren't entirely wrong — and what they found will make you look at the finale very differently.

2026/08/20 Report

ADVERTISEMENT

Why Thousands of Sherlock Fans Were Convinced There Was a Hidden Episode — And What the Creators Finally Admitted

In January 2017, something unusual happened in the Sherlock fan community.

Series Four had just aired its finale. The response was divisive — some viewers found the Eurus storyline satisfying, others felt it had resolved the show's central tensions too abruptly.

ADVERTISEMENT

But within days of the finale's broadcast, a specific group of fans had moved past the episode itself and toward a different question entirely.

Was there another one?

The theory — known in fan communities as "Tjlc" or the "lost episode" theory — proposed that the Series Four finale was not the actual finale.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

ADVERTISEMENT

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

Next page

Series 1 aired in 2010. Most of us were different people then. And somehow, watching it back now, the show knows that — and has things to say to who we became.

The Woman With No Name in the Script Who Reminded the Entire Audience Why Sherlock Holmes Has Mattered for 130 Years

Sherlock Holmes Outlived His Show. He Has Outlived Every Show. Here's Why Benedict Cumberbatch's Version Will Be the One That Lasts.

The Director Who Told Benedict Cumberbatch He Was Wrong About Sherlock Holmes. Cumberbatch Proved Him Right.

Benedict Cumberbatch Plays Sherlock Holmes Like a Man Who Is Secretly Terrified of Being Ordinary.

The Coat. The Cheekbones. The Collar. How Sherlock's Costume Was Designed to Make You Feel Inferior.

He Was Rejected From RADA Twice. Then He Became Sherlock Holmes.

What Really Happened? Dolly Parton Estate Suddenly Drops Case Against Nephew Bryan Seaver

Blue Bloods Shock: Will Estes Opens Up About Returning as Jamie Reagan — and Why He Was Nervous

Shock & Hope: NHL Prospect Austin Roest’s Emotional Update on Milly Okabe’s “Incurable” Diagnosis Sparks Outpouring of Support #StayStrong

Kris Jenner Fans Stunned After Corey Gamble’s Emotional “Wife” Message Sparks Fresh Wedding Rumors

Hollywood Shock: Nicholas Hoult Quietly Welcomes Twins as Pete Davidson Spills the News! #HowToRobABank

DWTS Shock: Sharna Burgess Admits Being Away From Zane Was Hard on Her “Mama Heart”

Allison Williams Steps Out With Brian Williams in Rare Father-Daughter Moment

“One Day Too Late”: Mom Reveals Haunting Details Before Caroline and James Lynch’s Deaths

Shocking Health Scare: Matt Damon Says Wife Luciana Faced Brain Aneurysm During “Oppenheimer” Season

Beverly Hills, 90210 Star Kimmarie Johnson Dies at 50 After Sudden Heart Emergency

Hailee Steinfeld Gets Emotional Over Daughter Harper’s Big Move: “She’s a Smart Cookie”

Beanie Feldstein’s Emotional Baby Joy: “Motherhood Is Unbelievably Beautiful” as She Welcomes Daughter

Travis Kelce Reveals His First Christmas With Taylor Swift After “Magical” Wedding