It Wasn’t Just a Breakup: Inside the Toxic Set Drama Behind Sophia Bush and Jesse Lee Soffer’s Split

Home

It Wasn’t Just a Breakup: Inside the Toxic Set Drama Behind Sophia Bush and Jesse Lee Soffer’s Split

2025/11/27 Report

ADVERTISEMENT

Sophia Bush and Jesse Lee Soffer’s breakup sits right at the crossroads of TV drama and real life – but the truth is a lot more complicated (and less gossipy) than fans sometimes imagine.

Sophia and Jesse met on the set of Chicago P.D., where they played fan-favorite couple Erin Lindsay and Jay Halstead.

ADVERTISEMENT

Their on-screen chemistry quickly became a talking point, and by 2014, outlets were reporting that the two were dating off-screen as well. They kept things low-key, and by mid-2015 the relationship had quietly ended, with reports simply noting that they had split but remained professional colleagues.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

ADVERTISEMENT

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

Next page

Beyond the Badge: How Tracy Spiridakos’ Real Life Breaks the Chicago P.D. Mold

Chicago P.D. Stars' Secret Roman Holiday Unveiled! Are On-Screen Partners Now Real-Life Besties?🚨 You Won't Believe the Cute Pics They Shared! 😱❤️

From Romance to Rivalry – How Sophia Bush & Jesse Lee Soffer Turned Personal Heartbreak into On-Screen Magic🔥

One Chicago Stars Who Left the Franchise: Discover What They’re Doing Now and Their New Ventures! 🌟💥

Chicago P.D. Bombshell: Jon Seda Reveals Secret Desire for Antonio Dawson's Return!💔🍕

The Launch Pad of Legends: The Secret List of A-Listers Who Used Y&R to Conquer Hollywood!

Chicago Fire’s Big Shake-Up — 2025’s Departures That Left Fans Reeling

The Heartwarming Brotherhood of Hawkeye, Trapper, and Radar: 4077's Most Iconic Friendship 💖

MAS*H's Heart & Soul: Hawkeye vs B.J. – Who Was the Real 'Doctor of the Soul?

From TV Heroes to Real-Life Legends: How MAS*H Cast Members Changed Over the Years ❤️

Unspoken Words: The Heart-Wrenching Final Conversation Between Hot Lips and Hawkeye 💔

Not On-Screen Lovers — But Real Life Sparks: Inside Torrey DeVitto and Jesse Lee Soffer’s Short-Lived Relationship

From Halstead & Upton to Real-Life Romance — What Fans Didn’t Know About Chicago P.D.

When the Last Producer Leaves the Set: The Final Chapter of MAS*H’s Era Comes to a Close ✨📺

MAS*H's Hidden Heroes: The Supporting Cast Who Stayed Out of the Spotlight, But Were Crucial to the Show's Success! 🎬✨

Radar’s Last Episode: The Emotional Reason Behind His Sudden Exit From MAS*H 💔

MAS*H's Hidden Gems: The Most Ironic Quotes You’ve Never Forgotten

Wedding’s Done — Now the Real Test Begins: What Season 12 Means for Burgess & Ruzek

10 MAS*H Moments That Will Bring Back All the Feels 😭❤️