For many, was once a shining example of how to retell a classic detective tale in modern times: sharp writing, clever deductions, charismatic leads, and modern-day London ambience. But over time, especially by its fourth season and beyond, a sense of disappointment grew among a significant chunk of the audience.
1. Repeated Mistakes, No Real Consequences
Critics have noted that the show’s lead — Sherlock Holmes (as portrayed in the series) — repeatedly behaves destructively, manipulates people close to him (especially John Watson), even resorts to drug use or betrayal — but the story rarely forces him to face real, lasting consequences.
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
Next page
